We originally got blue raspberry scent in the mail (it was labeled incorrectly for shipping) but when we contacted seller they replaced it immediately no questions asked. Once we got the actual watermelon scent, it smelled gorgeous. Doesn't quite smell like watermelon to me, but its still a really really pleasant scent and I do enjoy it. It is slightly on the pricier side, but it is a smaller company and not a giant corporations so more time and money goes into making each one, so I understand why it costs more